Chesterfield Declines Adding Eberwein Barn to Historic Landmark List
The move reflects a similar decision made two years ago, but goes against the hopes of the city's Historic Landmark and Preservation Commission.
A member of the Chesterfield Historic and Landmark Preservation Commission has raised concerns about a barn in Eberwein Park not being added to the city's list of historical landmarks.
The city decided to save the building almost two years ago when it bought the land that is now Eberwein Park. At the time, the property also had a family farmhouse, but the city council decided the structure was too expensive to restore, despite pleas from several residents to save it.
As a compromise, the city voted to spend $140,000 to historically restore the barn, but raze the house for $45,000 (estimates to restore the home as well were upwards of $300,000.) The renovation work on the barn is now nearly complete.
Preservation Commission member Todd Williams is part of the Chesterfield Heritage Foundation, an organization which advocated for saving the farmhouse and tried to raise money to do so, and told Patch that the barn deserves to be on the list.
"That's the only remaining remnant of that farm on the property," he said. "It's not a tin shed, it's not a portable building. What was left was an original barn from the Eberwein family."
Williams said he wanted to call attention to the situation after an unanimous decision by the commission to add the barn to the historic landmark list was declined by city staff, who said the city council had already previously decided against it.
Planning Director Aimee Nassif is the liason to the commission and said Chesterfield had looked at adding the building to the list two years ago when it first acquired the Eberwein property.
"It's an old structure, but it's not historic," she said, pointing to the fact that it has overhead garage doors.
However, Nassif added that the city has spent time and money restoring and stabilizing the barn and that there are no plans to remove it whatsoever.
D. Todd Williams
7:57 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
The City of Chesterfield has spent $4.4 million for this property, $600,000 building the dog park, $ 150,000 to restore the barn. I think the citizens of Chesterfield would like to give the property a little historical recognition by putting on the Chesterfield Historical Landmark list. Please visit http://www.facebook.com/pages/Chesterfield-Eberwein-Historical-Barn/117229435003642 if you would like more info on this property.
Joan Schacht
9:08 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
Although very narrow sighted, this is not surprising and certainly another loss for Chesterfield's historic preservation.
D. Todd Williams
9:27 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
This link is an article talking about the early settlers in Chesterfield, Henry Eberwein is part of this history. Henry's son is Ernst Eberwein who built the barn that currently is being worked on by the City of Chesterfield.
http://www.stltoday.com/suburban-journals/metro/news/sculpture-honors-early-chestfield-settlers-leaders-of-chesterfield-village/article_fd10b71a-dde9-559f-89c9-cc04c36f93c9.html
E J Anderson
10:19 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
I think this situation should push Chesterfield in the direction of finding an affordable means of historic preservation and reconstruction. Partner with Wash. U. or UMSL or some other school in the area with programs in architecture, engineering, and/or historical restoration and let the schools use the properties as training programs (with appropriate supervision, of course).
D. Todd Williams
10:25 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
EJ,
Awesome ideas, I hope the City of Chesterfield can take some of these ideas and put them in place.
E J Anderson
10:23 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012
Continuing . . . This has precedent in Faust Park where Wash U graduate students and volunteers conducted the archaeological digs and subsequest reports re. the Native American sites, and other grad students worked on designs and restoration of the Bates house and outbuildings with financial support from the Colonial Dames back in the 80's--I know, I was one of the high school kids working the archaeological digs! It didn't cost Chesterfield or the County Parks a penny!