patching...
Breaking: Tea Party Holds Protest Rally at West County IRS Office »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices
In awe of the universe and addicted to life.

Hidden Beneath a Veil of "Ignorance as a Value" Lies a 21st Century Mass Enlightenment

The Enlightenment we all know happened exactly as Wikipedia summarizes:

"...a cultural movement of intellectuals in 18th century Europe and the American colonies. Its purpose was to reform society using reason (rather than tradition, faith and revelation) and advance knowledge through science. It promoted science and intellectual interchange and opposed superstition, intolerance and some abuses by church and state.

Originating about 1650 to 1700, it was sparked by philosophers Baruch Spinoza, John Locke, Pierre Bayle, physicist Isaac Newton, and philosopher Voltaire. Ruling princes often endorsed and fostered figures and even attempted to apply their ideas of government in what was known as Enlightened Despotism. The Enlightenment flourished until about 1790–1800...

In France, Enlightenment was based in the salons and culminated in the great Encyclopédie edited by Denis Diderot with contributions by hundreds of leading philosophes (intellectuals) such as Voltaire, Rousseau, and Montesquieu. Some 25,000 copies of the 35 volume set were sold, half of them outside France. The new intellectual forces spread to urban centres across Europe, notably England, Scotland, the German states, the Netherlands, Russia, Italy, Austria, and Spain, then jumped the Atlantic into the European colonies, where it influenced Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson, among many others, and played a major role in the American Revolution. (emphasis mine) The political ideals of the Enlightenment influenced the American Declaration of Independence, the United States Bill of Rights, the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, and the Polish–Lithuanian Constitution of May 3, 1791."

Some of the products of this Enlightenment were our Constitution (a national and secular set of laws where God is not mentioned) Darwin, Niels Bohr, Tesla, Einstein, Karl Popper, Crick and Watson and more.

However, the ideals of the Enlightenment have waxed and waned over the ages, since the formation of our country.

Starting in about 1978, with the defeat of the Consumer Protection Agency under President Carter, regressive, pre-enlightenment philosophies started to regain credence in our country, and as a result, around the world.  In return, we have the current teetering economy, international instability, and a general uncertainty of a optimistic tomorrow to show for it.

However, within that same time frame, a 21st Century Enlightenment has begun to take shape.  Led by the likes of John Brockman, Nassim Taleb, Richard Dawkins, James Randi, Christopher Hitchens (recently deceased), Sam Harris, Stephen Hawking, Lawrence Krauss, Neil deGrasse Tyson, and Lisa Randall, for example.

Even more amazing are the millions of largely anonymous and unknown 21st Century enlightenment era thinkers and doers (The Mass Enlightenment) that will always remain nameless; yet, nonetheless have exponential influence on the growing body of knowledge that Brockman's group like's to call the 'Edge.'  As he said in his editorial named 'The Third Culture': "Throughout history, intellectual life has been marked by the fact that only a small number of people have done the serious thinking for everybody else. What we are witnessing is a passing of the torch from one group of thinkers, the traditional literary intellectuals, to a new group, the intellectuals of the emerging third culture."

As I said on my Facebook page recently, "The edges of human knowledge are pushed further out by the nano-second. It seems strange that it would run in parallel with the Tea Party [ignorance as a value] movement. Perhaps it's the 2nd renaissance [enlightenment] that caused the uproar of ignorance the Tea Party espouses. Sometimes the truth, (or additions/challenges to our perceived reality) can feel very frightening, alarming, discomforting, shocking, unsettling, and most of all...inconvenient to dogma and static ideologies."

It's the dialectical existance of both of these movements at the same time that make me feel slightly insecure about the future of humanity.  If history is any guide, one of these ideals can exist in the majority, but if enough of the general population subscribes to the other, the tension rises beyond congenial discourse and demotes itself to violence and self-destruction.

For what it's worth, as long as the Internet remains as an untamed and free range source of information disbursement (similar to how paper and moveable type spurred on the Rennaissance, and it's child, the Enlightenment,) our battles will remain mostly that of ideals and less likely the mangled dismemberment of humanity.

Hopefully.

Larry Lazar

7:05 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

Interesting and thoughtful piece Karl. What do think caused the return to pre-enlightenment philosophies? ie, why did we go backwards starting in the late 70's? Do you think a collective fear of the future was a factor?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Karl Frank Jr.

8:09 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

I should have included Stephen Pinker on this list. Can't wait to see him at the library!

Larry, I think that fear is at the root of almost everything we do. It's a death denial thing, largely subconscious. ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Denial_of_Death )

Or like the line from Dune, "Fear is the mind-killer, fear is the little death."

I tend to think that neo-conservatism, led by GOP party intellectuals, targeted the "ignorance as a value" group to rally support for their causes. "They need numbers and people to vote against their own financial interests."

Corporations were being hammered with common sense regulations in the 70s and by 1978 with the Consumer Protection Agency, they banded together to defeat the CPA. They smelled blood.

Now the neo-conservative intellectuals had their ideas, their money, and their "ignorance as a value" constituency.

As a result, the Democrats realized they were in trouble and couldn't operate without the support of the corporate movement. They ingratiated themselves to corporate interests by putting them before everyone else in order to get some of their social interests the light of day.

The end result is that the vast majority of media is owned by a small monopoly of corporations that reports at a 3rd to 8th grade level, which obviously appeals to the "ignorance as a value" crowd. By 2000, the founders of the PNAC inherited the White House and gave us the worse decade in recent memory. But...

Karl Frank Jr.

8:20 am on Monday, September 24, 2012

(continued)

...as long as the Internet remains open and free, the Mass Enlightenment, will continue to grow.

However, I really feel like that as long as corporations have person-hood status, it's an uphill battle. Especially with multi-national corporations that are in many ways above the law. (Also a result of globalization and the Internet.) Double-edged sword I guess, but the freedom side is a little sharper.

Politics in the "now" was always set in motion 20-40 years previous. What we have to work for now is the political America we want to 20 years from now.

Reply

Sensible? I think so

7:39 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

Yes, interesting and thoughtful. Esp. the Internet's role in speeding up the propagation of ideas, bad and good. And how it's a preferred battleground for settling differences.

Thomas Frank (coincidence?) has explored how the right has been able to convince people to do things not in their personal best interest, and how it's been able to use social issues to hide the issues worth discussing. "What's the Matter with Kansas?" is over the top with examples but has some interesting ideas. One of my favorite quotes from him:

"Bad government is the natural product of rule by those who believe government is bad."

http://www.tcfrank.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Frank

Reply

Karl Frank Jr.

9:09 pm on Monday, September 24, 2012

It definitely works both ways.

But I think there is a common thread among those types all have in common, which is where Carl Sagan's "Baloney Detection Kit" comes from.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUB4j0n2UDU

I would add a second caveat...If it has a black background...move on. :)

I think in these forums, the truth eventually rises to the top, you will always have your flat earth society lingering around. Snopes.com being a good example of how to stop some misinformation.

Technical literacy is certainly important in today's education. I don't just mean using computers, but how programming works and how computers works and how it can all be used against you or to manipulate you.

http://web.missouri.edu/~segerti/capstone/deliverusfromevil.pdf

Reply

Karl Frank Jr.

8:27 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Here is an excellent op-ed in the New York Times from Conservative David Brooks touching on the "Ignorance as a Value" crowd, especially those in his party.

Brooks has been an interesting fellow to watch over the years. He is precisely the kind of intellectual conservative that has been marginalized by the "Ignorance as a Value" power structure of the GOP.

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/opinion/brooks-the-conservative-mind.html?_r=2

Reply

Leave a comment